The Real In-Betweener
I’ve been pondering about YA these days, mostly because I’m at the point where I just can’t read another one. Why? I’m not sure. I have been nothing but staunch in my support of children’s fiction, but lately it’s been like pulling teeth to get me to crack one open. Like anything that’s popular, oversaturation in the market can lead to a diluting of genre, but I don’t think that’s it. I never read YA because it was trendy; I read YA because I have always loved it.
Perhaps I am fond of YA because it was the age when I first became transformed by reading, but then again, maybe I’m remembering it wrong. I don’t remember any particular age when I wasn’t reading for pleasure; after all, I was the sort of child my parents had to remind to “put the book away at the dinner table, please” and “for heaven’s sake, stop reading in the car; you know it makes you sick!”
In college, when reading had become both a joy and an agony (reading JANE EYRE for the millionth time? Yay! Slogging through CONFESSIONS OF AN ENGLISH OPIUM-EATER? Nay!), I returned to the books I had loved and cherished as a child for comfort. It wasn’t that they were all children’s books–my copy of LE FANTÔME DE L’OPERA is pretty much destroyed from being read so often–but they were familiar stories, something in which I could take unalloyed pleasure without having to worry overmuch about critical analysis. (I do subject everything I read to critical analysis–the English major, she is hard to turn off.) I think a large part of my affection is colored by nostalgia.
But recently I’ve been troubled by a sense of disconnect in my YA reading; that is, what I held dear about children’s fiction is missing from most of the YA I see now. Warning: Mostly my musings beneath the cut. May offend or infuriate some. Or not. Just my thoughts, people, no judgment.
















